Bad Faith Claim Survives Summary Judgment
June 08, 2026 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiThe court denied the insurer’s motion for partial summary judgment on the insured’s bad faith claim, but granted the motion on the insured’s claim for punitive damages. Serbian Orthodox Church v. Brotherhood Mut. Ins. Co., 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 58234 (S.D. Cal. March 19, 2026).
On February 1, 2023, the Church filed a claim for water damage with Brotherhood Mutual Insurance Company (BMIC). The claim was based on rain and wind that caused extensive water intrusion into the Sanctuary, damaging its plaster walls and ceilings and fresco paintings. The claim was assigned to Patrick Hurley. Hurley sent a letter discussing potential bars to coverage and requesting further information and documents from the Church.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Tred R. Eyerly, Damon Key Leong Kupchak HastertMr. Eyerly may be contacted at
te@hawaiilawyer.com
Eleventh Circuit Permits Florida Restrictions on Property Ownership by Certain Foreign Nationals to Go Forward
January 13, 2026 —
Minyao Wang - Lewis Brisbois NewsroomNew York, N.Y. (December 4, 2025) - On November 4, 2025, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit issued a long-anticipated decision in
Shen v. Simpson, upholding the constitutionality of a Florida
law, SB 264, which restricts ownership of or investment in Florida real estate by individuals “domiciled” in the People’s Republic of China and to a lesser extent, other countries of concern (which are identified in the statute as Russia, North Korea, Iran, Cuba, Venezuela and Syria) who are not American citizens or green card holders. The restriction encompasses residential, commercial and agricultural real estate. Oral argument in the case was held on April 19, 2024, and it took the court almost one year and seven months to issue its opinion, an unusually long turn-around time.
This Update follows previous Lewis Brisbois alerts on Florida’s law and legal challenges to it.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Minyao Wang, Lewis BrisboisMr. Wang may be contacted at
Minyao.Wang@lewisbrisbois.com
FTC Issues Warning Letters to Property Management Software Providers on Price Transparency
January 26, 2026 —
Christine Tenley, Patrick A. Garcia & Michael Hettig - Lewis BrisboisAtlanta, Ga. (December 23, 2025) - On December 8, 2025 the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) sent what it is describing as a “Warning Letter” to companies that provide property management software to landlords (“Software Providers”). While the letter does not speak specifically to landlords, landlords can still use the information contained in the letter to adopt best practices to avoid potential enforcement action.
The Warning Letter references two high profile civil enforcement actions the FTC has undertaken in the last two years: FTC v. Invitation Homes, and FTC v. Greystar Real Estate Partners, LLC, et al., two cases in which the FTC targeted landlords for what it deemed unfair or deceptive advertising practices. Citing those cases, the FTC warns software providers that they must provide platforms on which landlords can accurately advertise the total monthly cost of a rental property rather than simply advertising the monthly rental payment. The FTC then warns that failure to create platforms that share the total monthly payments may result in enforcement action.
Reprinted courtesy of
Christine Tenley, Lewis Brisbois,
Patrick A. Garcia, Lewis Brisbois and
Michael Hettig, Lewis Brisbois
Ms. Tenley may be contacted at Christine.Tenley@lewisbrisbois.com
Mr. Garcia may be contacted at Patrick.Garcia@lewisbrisbois.com
Mr. Hettig may be contacted at Michael.Hettig@lewisbrisbois.com
Read the full story...
Insurer Granted Summary Judgment on Claim for Roof Damage Caused by Windstorm
May 26, 2026 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiThe insurer successfully moved for summary judgment, eliminating the insured’s claim for roof damage due to windstorm. Mulas v. Westchester Surplus Lines Ins. Co., 2026 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 20537 (Jan. 30, 2026).
The insureds’ commercial property sustained windstorm damage during Hurricane Ian. Westchester denied the claim. The insureds believed Westchester wrongfully denied coverage for roof damage and various interior damage to property. The insureds also argued that Westchester’s actual cash value (ACV) payment did not reflect the fully insured loss.
The insureds sued and Westchester moved for summary judgment. Westchester argued the roof damage was not covered because Hurricane Ian did not cause the damage. Westchester hired an engineer who determined the roof damage was not caused by wind from Hurricane Ian. Westchester pointed out that the insureds’ expert also found no wind damage on the roof. The insureds offered no other evidence suggesting the hurricane caused roof damage. Therefore, the insureds could not show that Westchester breached the policy by denying coverage.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Tred R. Eyerly, Damon Key Leong Kupchak HastertMr. Eyerly may be contacted at
te@hawaiilawyer.com
Ball Janik LLP Elevates Construction Litigation Attorneys Keegan A. Berry and Nicholas B. Vargo to Partner
February 02, 2026 —
Ball Janik LLPOrlando, FL – January 28, 2026 –
Ball Janik LLP is pleased to announce the elevation of
Keegan A. Berry and
Nicholas B. Vargo to Partner, effective 2026. Both attorneys are dedicated to their clients and have provided significant contributions to the firm's Construction Defect and Litigation practice.
"Keegan and Nicholas exemplify the excellence and client-focused approach that define Ball Janik LLP," said James C. Prichard, Managing Partner of Ball Janik LLP. "Their elevation to Partner reflects not only their exceptional legal skills and dedication to our clients but also their commitment to advancing the firm's mission. We are proud to recognize their achievements and look forward to their continued leadership."
Berry is based in Ball Janik LLP's Orlando office and is a Florida Bar Board Certified Specialist in Construction Law. Throughout his career, Berry has focused on complex litigation and resolving matters through arbitration, alternative dispute resolution, and trial, with extensive experience both prosecuting and defending construction claims on behalf of owners, contractors, and manufacturers. His practice also encompasses complex commercial and general litigation, including business torts, professional liability, products liability, and general liability.
"I'm honored to continue serving Florida's business and property owner communities as a partner at Ball Janik, leveraging my experience to deliver efficient, results-driven solutions in even the most complex construction disputes," said Berry.
Vargo is based in Ball Janik LLP's Tampa office and is a Florida Bar Board Certified Specialist in Construction Law. He focuses on Construction Litigation, representing residential and commercial property owners in construction defect litigation. Vargo has spent most of his career in construction defect law with Ball Janik and has been instrumental in growing Ball Janik's presence in Florida's west coast.
"Becoming a partner at Ball Janik is both a privilege and a responsibility, and I look forward to continuing to advocate fiercely for our clients while holding accountable those who attempt to evade their obligations," said Vargo.
About Ball Janik LLP
Ball Janik LLP is a Florida-based law firm offering construction defect, construction law, insurance recovery, and commercial litigation counsel, to its local and national clients. The firm was founded in 1982 and has expanded its capabilities, professionals, and geographic footprint. What started as a small firm focused on real property, land use, and litigation (known then as Ball Janik & Novack) has grown to a team of 50-plus attorneys and paralegals in 5 offices in Florida, with centuries of combined experience and capabilities. The firm has been recognized by Chambers USA, U.S. News & World Report and Best Lawyers®, The Best Lawyers in America©, and Corporate International. Read more here: https://www.balljanik.com/.
Kahana Feld Secures Discontinuance with Prejudice in Fraudulent Case
January 06, 2026 —
Kahana FeldKahana Feld secured a victory for its client after uncovering evidence that the plaintiff’s alleged trip-and-fall claim was fraudulent. The plaintiff sought $8 million in damages and claimed serious spinal and knee injuries stemming from an incident outside a Bronx retail store.
Through strategic investigation and a crucial non-party deposition, our team established that the plaintiff’s identified eyewitness was out of the country at the time of the alleged accident—contradicting the plaintiff’s testimony and confirming the falsity of the claim.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Kahana Feld
Government Claiming Contract Is Void Ab Initio by Contractor Knowingly Making False Statements
January 06, 2026 —
David Adelstein - Florida Construction Legal UpdatesCan the federal government declare a contract “void ab initio” or void from the beginning? Yes, if the government can “prove that the contractor (a) obtained the contract by (b) knowingly (c) making a false statement.” MLB Transportation v. U.S., 2025 WL 2962897, *8 (Fed.Cl. 2025) (citation omitted).
Where a contractor “obtained [a] contract by knowingly falsely stating that it was a small business … [the] government contract [is] tainted from its inception by fraud [and] is void ab initio.” The general rule that “a Government contract tainted by fraud or wrong-doing is void ab initio … protects the integrity of the federal contracting process and safeguards the public from undetectable threats to the public fisc.” A contract found to be void ab initio has “no legal effect,” and is “[n]ull from the beginning, as from the first moment when a contract is entered into.”
MLB Transportation, supra (citations omitted).
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
David Adelstein, Kirwin NorrisMr. Adelstein may be contacted at
dma@kirwinnorris.com
2026 Colorado Super Lawyers Recognizes 11 Snell & Wilmer Attorneys
May 05, 2026 —
Snell & WilmerDENVER – Snell & Wilmer is pleased to announce that eleven attorneys in its Denver office have been selected for inclusion in the 2026 Colorado Super Lawyers publication. Of those eleven, four were recognized as Rising Star
Anti-Concurrent Causation Clause Preserves Possibility of CoverageServing Notice of Nonpayment Under Miller ActNY Estimating Consultant Settles $3.1M Government Project Fraud CaseLitigation Roundup: “You Can’t Make Me Pay!”“Pay No Attention to the Man Behind the Curtain!”Genuine Dispute Over Cause of Damage and Insureds’ Demolition Before Inspection Negate Bad Faith and Elder Abuse ClaimsPartners Patti Santelle and Gale White honored by as "Top Women in Law" The Legal IntelligencerCreate a Culture of Safety to Improve Labor Recruitment EffortsContractual “Pay if Paid” and “Pay when Paid” Clauses? What is a California Construction Subcontractor to Do? CGL Insurer’s Duty To Defend Broader Than Duty To Indemnify And Based On Allegations In Underlying ComplaintSun, Sand and Stir-Fry? Miami Woos Chinese for Property: CitiesAm I Still Covered Under the Title Insurance Policy?Remand of Bad Faith Claim Evidences Split Among Florida District CourtsCalifornia Supreme Court Adopts “Vertical Exhaustion” in the Long-Storied Montrose Environmental Coverage LitigationChallenging Enforceability of Liquidated Damages (In Federal Construction Context)New Jersey Law regarding Prior Expert’s TestimonyConstruction Injuries Under the Privette Doctrine. An Electrifying, but Perhaps Not Particularly Shocking, Story . . .Industry Practices Questioned After Girder Fractures at Salesforce Transit CenterNo Coverage Based Upon Your Prior Work ExclusionConstruction Law Alert: A Specialty License May Not Be Required If Work Covered By Another LicenseInsurer's Motion for Summary Judgment on Business Interruption Claim DeniedFew Homes Available to Reno Buyers, Plenty of Commercial PropertiesCalifornia insured’s duty to cooperate and insurer’s right to select defense counselWildfire Threats Make Utilities Uninsurable in US WestFlorida Decides Against Adopting DaubertWhy Are Developers Still Pouring Billions Into Waterlogged Miami?Developer Transition – Washington DC CondominiumsNoteworthy Construction Defect Cases for 1st Qtr 2014General Contractors Can Be Sued by a Subcontractor’s Injured EmployeePartner Bradley T. Guldalian Secures Summary Judgment Win for National Hotel ChainSewage Treatment Agency Sues Insurer and Contractor after Wall Failure and Sewage LeakThese Roads Aren’t Built for Wilder Weather Driven by Climate ChangeThree's a Trend: Second, Fourth and Ninth Circuits Uphold Broad "Related Claims" LanguageBuy a House or Pay Off College? $1.2 Trillion Student Debt Heats Up in CapitalHow VR and AR Will Help in Remote Expert AssistanceClaim for Vandalism Loss Survives Motion to DismissCalifornia Booms With FivePoint New Schools: Real EstateMake Sure to Properly Perfect and Preserve Construction Lien RightsAppeals Court Upholds Skanska, Granite Win in ‘I-4 Ultimate’ JV DisputeMold Due to Construction Defects May Temporarily Close Fire StationBuilding Group Has Successful 2012, Looks to 2013The Colorado Court of Appeals Rules that a Statutory Notice of Claim Triggers an Insurer’s Duty to Defend. Pennsylvania Civil Engineers Give the State's Infrastructure a "C-" GradeAnother Possible “Out” of Uniwest?Thomson Reuters Construction Law (Virginia Practice Series)Real Estate & Construction News Round-Up (08/10/22)Judge Gives Cintra Bid Protest of $9B Md. P3 Project Award New LifeWant to Make Your Jobsite Safer? Look to the Skies.Kahana Feld Receives 2024 OCCDL Top Legal Organizations for DEI AwardLate Notice Bars Insured’s Claim for Wind DamageBoilerplate Contract Language on Permits could cause Problems for ContractorsYear and a Half Old Las Vegas VA Emergency Room Gets RebuiltNYC Shuts 9 Pre-Kindergartens for Health, Safety IssuesDowntown Sacramento Building Riddled with DefectsConstruction Defects in Roof May Close School
