Doctrine of Substantial Performance When It Comes to Payment
July 27, 2026 —
David Adelstein - Florida Construction Legal UpdatesA recent non-construction case touches upon the doctrine of substantial performance when it comes to payment. In this case, a club was to make two payments to secure a rapper’s attendance. The first payment was made. The second payment was made but was a few hundred dollars short of the agreed amount. The rapper did not show up. The club claimed it substantially performed its obligations. At first glance, the argument makes sense because the second payment fell only a few hundred dollars short. But that wasn’t the case when it comes to pre-commencement payment obligations:
Substantial performance applies only when the variance from the contract terms “is inadvertent or unintentional and unimportant so that the work actually performed is substantially what was called for in the contract.” However, when one party agrees to pay the other on or before a specific date, time is of the essence, and the payor is required to pay the payee on or before that date. “There is almost always no such thing as ‘substantial performance’ of payment between commercial parties when the duty is simply the general one to pay. Payment is either made in the amount and on the date due, or it is not.”
Big Gate Records, LLC v. Washington, 51 Fla.L.Weekly D1281a (Fla. 2nd DCA 2026) (internal citations omitted).
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
David Adelstein, Kirwin NorrisMr. Adelstein may be contacted at
dma@kirwinnorris.com
Denis Serkin and Michael S. Zicherman Co-Edit/Author Lexology Panoramic: Construction 2027
August 03, 2026 —
Denis Serkin & Michael S. Zicherman - Peckar & Abramson, P.C.P&A partners
Denis Serkin and
Michael S. Zicherman served as co-editors and authors of Lexology’s Panoramic: Construction 2027 – US and Global guide. Formerly Getting the Deal Through, Lexology Panoramic provides members of the construction industry and construction-related legal and business providers with side-by-side comparison of key industry issues in 19 jurisdictions worldwide.
Reprinted courtesy of
Denis Serkin, Peckar & Abramson, P.C. and
Michael S. Zicherman, Peckar & Abramson, P.C.
Mr. Serkin may be contacted at dserkin@pecklaw.com
Mr. Zicherman may be contacted at mzicherman@pecklaw.com
Read the full story...
Safeguarding Your Privileged Construction Information With a Clawback Agreement
June 08, 2026 —
Laura Fraher - Construction ExecutiveFor contractors and construction executives, a
dispute that escalates to litigation brings risks that go well beyond the jobsite. When a dispute escalates to litigation, the attorney-client privilege is a critical protection to safeguard your interests. Disclosing privileged material can undermine your litigation position and, in some cases, negatively impact your business. In the construction context, this often includes sensitive communications about project delays, defect investigations, safety incidents or payment disputes—materials that can significantly impact both liability and reputation.
During litigation, the discovery process requires the exchange of documents and data with your adversary. If privileged materials are disclosed to your adversary during discovery you risk the waiver of your privilege, which in plain terms means you lose the protection of the privilege and make the privileged information, and in some cases all other information related to the same subject matter, available to your adversary. It is critical that your attorney take steps to protect against the unintentional disclosure of privileged materials during discovery to avoid a waiver.
Reprinted courtesy of
Laura Fraher, Construction Executive, a publication of Associated Builders and Contractors. All rights reserved.
Read the full story...Ms. Fraher may be contacted at
lfraher@barclaydamon.com
Builders Oppose Senate Housing Bill Over Investor Ban Provision
March 24, 2026 —
Katy O'Donnell - BloombergA powerful group representing the nation’s home builders is coming out against the most significant housing legislation in more than a decade over a provision negotiated by the White House that would restrict institutional investors from purchasing single-family homes.
The builders’ objection could imperil the bill’s chances of becoming law, even as leaders of both parties are desperate to show they are doing something to alleviate voters’
cost-of-living concerns. The Senate voted 90-8 to clear a procedural hurdle for the bill on Wednesday, with a vote on final passage expected early next week.
The inclusion of the investor ban in a broader housing bill was key to getting the White House on board,
Senate Banking Committee Chairman Tim Scott, a Republican from South Carolina, told reporters Tuesday.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Katy O'Donnell, Bloomberg
The Goal Is the Repair, Not the Lawsuit: What Colorado HOA Boards Should Consider Before Suing a Builder
September 08, 2026 —
Gail Gudder - Colorado Construction Litigation BlogFourteen years ago, we cautioned Colorado homeowners associations against a “ready, fire, aim” approach to construction-defect litigation. In
The Hidden Dangers of Construction Defect Litigation, we suggested a fairly simple proposition: when legitimate construction defects exist, the goal should be to get them repaired. Litigation should be a last resort, not an end in itself.
Much has changed in Colorado construction-defect law since then. But a recent Douglas County case, and significant amendments to the Colorado Common Interest Ownership Act (“CCIOA”) enacted in 2025, provide good reasons for HOA board members and owners to revisit that basic premise.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Gail Gudder, Higgins, Hopkins, McLain & Roswell, LLCMs. Gudder may be contacted at
gudder@hhmrlaw.com
Construction Liens and the “Substantial Performance” Doctrine
April 08, 2026 —
David Adelstein - Florida Construction Legal UpdatesIn a recent case dealing with a construction lien, the driving issue was whether the air conditioning contractor “substantially performed” before recording its construction lien against residential property. The importance here pertains to the substantial performance doctrine with respect to construction liens. The Third District Court of Appeal explained, with relevant citations, this doctrine as follows:
Under Florida law, a contractor is entitled to a mechanic’s lien if he complies with all provisions of Chapter 713, governing construction liens, and “has substantially performed the contract.” Grant v. Wester, 679 So. 2d 1301, 1307 (Fla. 1st DCA 1996) (quotation omitted); Langley v. Knowles, 958 So. 2d 1149, 1151 (Fla. 5th DCA 2007) (“The substantial performance doctrine recognizes that a contactor who complies with all of the provisions of the contactor’s lien statute is entitled to enforce a lien if he has substantially, but not completely, performed his contractual obligations.”). Substantial performance is performance “so nearly equivalent to what was bargained for that it would be unreasonable to deny the promisee the full contract price subject to the promisor’s right to recover whatever damages may have been occasioned him by the promisee’s failure to render full performance.” Ocean Ridge Dev. Corp. v. Quality Plastering, Inc., 247 So. 2d 72, 75 (Fla. 4th DCA 1971).
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
David Adelstein, Kirwin NorrisMr. Adelstein may be contacted at
dma@kirwinnorris.com
Fatalities Edge Down: New Data Reveals a Promising Decline
April 27, 2026 —
Construction ExecutiveConstruction fatalities in the United States declined slightly in 2024, according to
new data released from the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics. The sector recorded just over 1,000 worker deaths last year—a modest decrease from the previous year but still among the highest totals of any industry.
Falls remained the leading cause of death, accounting for roughly one-third of all construction fatalities. Transportation incidents—including workers struck by vehicles or equipment—ranked second, followed by contact with objects or equipment and electrocutions.
Reprinted courtesy of
Construction Executive, a publication of Associated Builders and Contract
Georgia Court Rules that Separate Settlements Are Not the End of the Matter Measure of Damages in Negligent Procurement of Surety Bonds / InsuranceFederal Public Works Construction Collection Remedies: The Miller Act Payment Bond ClaimIf We Want Affordable Housing, Local Governments Must Look in the MirrorAssociation Bound by Arbitration Provision in Purchase-And-Sale Contracts and DeedsFlorida Litigation Team Delivers Crushing Summary Judgment Victory for National Home BuilderWill a Notice of Non-Responsibility Prevent Enforcement of a California Mechanics Lien?New Jersey Condominium Owners Sue FEMAOfficial Tried to Influence Judge against Shortchanged SubcontractorNo Coverage for Repairs Made Before Suit FiledApartment Boom in Denver a Shortcut Around Condo Construction Defect Suits?Lessons from the Sept. 19 Mexico EarthquakeIs the Issuance of a City Use Permit Referable? Not When It Is an Administrative ActRenee Zellweger Selling Connecticut Country HomeArizona Supreme Court Leaves Limits on Construction Defects UnclearThe Uncertain Future of the IECCNYC Airports Get $500,000 Makeover Contest From CuomoCraig Holden Named Top 100 Lawyer by Los Angeles Business JournalNerves of Steel Needed as Firms Face Volatile Prices, Broken Contracts and Price-GougingMore Musings on Why I MediateFirst Circuit Finds No Coverage For Subcontracted Faulty WorkPennsylvania Supreme Court: Fair Share Act Does Not Preempt Common Law When Apportioning LiabilityClient Alert: Absence of a Court Reporter at a Civil Motion Hearing May Preclude Appellate ReviewBusiness Interruption, Food Spoilage Claims Resulting from Off Premise Power Failure DeniedInsurer Entitled to Reimbursement of Defense Costs Under Unjust Enrichment TheoryArchitect Norman Foster Tells COP26: Change 'Traditional' City Design to Combat Climate ChangeBuyer Alleges Condo Full of Mold and MiceColorado Passes Construction Defect Reform BillFlorida Lien Law and Substantial Compliance vs. Strict ComplianceHomebuilding Still on the RiseLA Blazes Bolster Case for Wildfire-Tech Investment, VC Clerico SaysThe Colorado Supreme Court holds that loans made to a construction company are not subject to the Mechanic’s Lien Trust Fund StatuteAnti-Concurrent Causation Clause Bars Coverage for Pool DamageBeyond the Disneyland Resort: World Class Shopping ExperiencesThe Condo Conundrum: 10 Reasons Why There's a 'For Sale' Shortage in SeattleFlatiron Said Disputed Concrete Mix Cost Millions on Large Caltrans ProjectFor Breach of Contract Claim, There Needs to be a Breach of a Contractual DutyNo Coverage Under Exclusions For Wind and Water DamageDefects in Texas High School Stadium Angers ResidentsCEO/Founding Principal Nicole Whyte is recognized as one of the most Influential Leaders in Orange County by the OC Business Journal!Coverage Exists for Landlord as Additional InsuredScaffolding Purchase Suggests No New Building for Board of EqualizationCourt Upholds Appraisers' Use of "Increased Cost of Construction" ProvisionDon’t Overlook Leading Edge HazardsIs the Manhattan Bank of America Tower a Green Success or Failure?Word of the Day: “Contractor”Los Angeles Considering Census of Seismically Unstable BuildingsContractual Waiver of Consequential DamagesBuilders Can’t Rely on SB800New Jersey Court Adopts Continuous Trigger for Construction Defect ClaimsCampaign Improve Jobsite Safety?
July 1, 2015 Statutory Changes Affecting Virginia Contractors and SubcontractorsTick Tock: Don’t Let the Statute of Repose or Limitations Time Periods Run on Your Construction ClaimsSegal McCambridge Recognized in 2026 Chambers USA RankingsDocumenting Contract Changes in ConstructionThe Sounds of Silence: Pennsylvania’s Sutton RuleSettlement Agreement? It Ain’t Over ‘Til it’s . . . Final, in Writing, Fully Executed, and Admissible Hunton’s Alice Weeks Selected to the Miami Dade Bar’s Circle of Excellence for Insurance LitigationOne to Watch: Case Takes on Economic Loss Rule and Professional DutiesCause Still Unclear in March Retaining Wall Collapse on $900M NJ InterchangeSochi Construction Unlikely to be Completed by End of Olympic GamesBusiness Risk Exclusion Dooms Coverage for Construction Defect ClaimGoogle, Environmentalists and University Push Methane-Leak DetectionStructural Problems May Cause Year-Long Delay Opening New Orleans SchoolNTSB Outlines Pittsburgh Bridge Structure Specifics, Finding Collapse Cause Will Take Months
