Appraisal Can Go Forward Prior to Resolution of Coverage Dispute
April 08, 2024 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiThe Florida Supreme Court found that a trial court could compel an appraisal of the insured's loss prior to resolving coverage issues. Am. Coastal Ins. Co. v. San Marco Villas Condo. Ass'n, Inc., 2024 Fla. LEXIS 185 (Fla. Feb. 1, 2024).
Hurricane Irma damaged San Marco Condominium Association's buildings. American Coastal paid $192,629.75 for the loss. San Marco estimated the damage to be in excess of eight million dollars. San Marco demanded an appraisal under the policy. American Coastal refused to submit to appraisal because it was premature as its investigation was still ongoing.
San Marco sued American Coastal and asked the court to compel appraisal. American Coastal argued that San Marco had committed fraud or had made material misrepresentations regarding its claim. The trial court heard San Marco's appraisal motion and entered an order compelling appraisal. American Coastal appealed, bu the Second District Court affirmed.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Tred R. Eyerly, Damon Key Leong Kupchak HastertMr. Eyerly may be contacted at
te@hawaiilawyer.com
Are Construction Contract Limitation of Liability Clauses on the Way Out in Virginia?
March 11, 2024 —
Christopher G. Hill - Construction Law MusingsRemember BAE Systems and Fluor? This post is the third here at Construction Law Musings relating to this case which is a seemingly never-ending source for content. In the prior post discussing this case, the Court found that Va. Code 1-4.1:1 which bars waiver of a right to payment before work is performed did not apply because Fluor had provided work before execution of the contract or any change orders.
In the most recent opinion in this long-running litigation, and after a motion to reconsider by Fluor that was granted, the Court re-examined this finding along with the contractual language found in the Limitation of Damages (LOD) clause and came to the opposite conclusion regarding certain change orders that remained unpaid by BAE.
The Court first looked to the language of the contract itself and specifically the language in the LOD provision that states “Except as otherwise provided in this Subcontract.” The Court then looked at the change order provision and its typical equitable adjustment language and the mandatory nature of the equitable adjustment language. The Court found that the LOD provisions did not apply to change orders both because price increases due to change orders are not “damages” and because of the exception language in the LOD provision itself.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
The Law Office of Christopher G. HillMr. Hill may be contacted at
chrisghill@constructionlawva.com
Mass Timber Reduces Construction’s Carbon Footprint, But Introduces New Risk Scenarios
March 04, 2024 —
Michael Bruch & Franck Fumat - Allianz CommercialMass timber has the potential to be a critical building component for the cities of the near future given the need for the construction sector to reduce its reliance on concrete and steel to lower its Co2 emissions. However, as this market grows and mass timber buildings evolve to greater heights, the construction risk landscape will also be transformed, bringing risk management challenges for companies, according to the new Emerging Risk Trend Talk
report from Allianz Commercial.
“The emergence of mass timber as a sustainable construction alternative represents a significant opportunity for the building sector to reduce its carbon footprint while also satisfying a demand for a material that is more cost-efficient but as durable as steel and concrete,” says Michael Bruch, Global Head of Risk Advisory Services at Allianz Commercial. “However, in any industry, deployment of new materials or processes can result in new risk scenarios, potential defects, or unexpected safety consequences, as well as bringing benefits, and mass timber is no different. Given this market’s expected future growth, companies should do all they can to develop a greater understanding of their exposures including fire, water damage, repetitive loss scenarios and even termite infestation, and ensure they have robust loss prevention measures in place to combat these.”
The need for mass timber
The building and construction sector is among the largest contributors to Co2 emissions, accounting for over 34% of energy demand and around 37% of energy and process related Co2 emissions in
2021 [1]. Given emissions reduction is essential to meet climate change commitments around the world, the need for more sustainable solutions in the built environment has become increasingly important, driven by growing investor and consumer concerns, and legislation, regulation and reporting requirements evolving quickly in many jurisdictions around the world.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Allianz Commercial
A New Lawsuit Might Change the Real Estate Industry Forever
December 23, 2023 —
Tracy Alloway, Joe Weisenthal, and Aashna Shah - BloombergLast month, a Missouri jury found that real estate brokers colluded to artificially inflate and fix their own commissions, and as a result, ordered the National Association of Realtors to pay $1.8 billion in damages. While the ruling will be appealed, with highly uncertain damages and remedies, the case is shining a light on how participants in the real estate industry get paid, and raising the question of whether homebuyers are paying too much to their brokers. So how do brokers get paid? What are their incentives? And why haven't fees for brokers gone down, even as online platforms that compete with them have proliferated. On this episode of the podcast, we speak with Andra Ghent, a finance professor at the University of Utah and a specialist in real estate who explains how the structure works currently, and how the lawsuit could ultimately change the entire business model of buying and selling homes. This transcript has been lightly edited for clarity.
Reprinted courtesy of
Tracy Alloway, Bloomberg,
Joe Weisenthal, Bloomberg and
Aashna Shah, Bloomberg Read the full story...
Courthouse Reporter Series: The Bizarre Case That Required a 117-Year-Old Expert
December 04, 2023 —
Todd Heffner & Di'Vennci Lucas - The Dispute ResolverA recent decision by the Georgia Court of Appeals, Munro v. Georgia Department of Transportation, highlights how overly specific and inflexible rules of evidence can create peculiar results.
Munro involved a dispute over the design of a Georgia intersection. No. A23A0404, 2023 WL 4194716 (Ga. Ct. App. June 27, 2023). The plaintiff alleged that the defendant improperly designed the intersection, never corrected that improper design, and failed to properly maintain the intersection. These claims were dismissed for a very odd reason: the plaintiff’s expert witness wasn’t old enough.
The case arose from a car accident. A vehicle in which the plaintiff Munro was a passenger collided with a tractor trailer crossing an intersection. Munro sued the Georgia Department of Transportation (DOT) for negligently designing, maintaining, and inspecting the intersection. The DOT filed a motion to dismiss for lack of subject matter jurisdiction on the ground of sovereign immunity and a motion to exclude the testimony of the Munros’ expert witness, among other motions. The trial court dismissed the case in full on the sovereign immunity ground and denied the other motions as moot. The Munros appealed.
Reprinted courtesy of
Todd Heffner, Troutman Pepper and
Di'Vennci Lucas, Troutman Pepper Read the full story...Mr. Heffner may be contacted at
todd.heffner@troutman.com
Appellate Court of Maryland Construes Notice Conditions of A312 Performance Bond in Favor of Surety
January 02, 2024 —
Joel P. Williams - White and Williams LLPThe Appellate Court of Maryland issued a reported opinion in a case construing an American Institute of Architects (“AIA”) A312 performance bond. In Wildewood Operating Company, LLC v. WRV Holdings, LLC, et al. 2023 Md. App. LEXIS 720 (Oct. 30, 2023), the Appellate Court of Maryland held that a performance bond surety was discharged from liability where the owner/obligee failed to give the surety notice of the contractor’s default termination until after a third party had completed the work.
The project concerned the construction of an assisted living facility in St. Mary’s County, Maryland. The owner, Wildewood Operating Company, LLC, entered into an A312-2010 performance bond with Clark Turner Construction, LLC, as contractor, and First Indemnity of America Insurance Company, as surety. When Clark Turner failed to complete certain stormwater management work adjacent to the site, Wildewood, Clark Turner, and other parties entered into a Work Agreement to address completion of the work. The surety was not a party to the Work Agreement.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Joel P. Williams, White and Williams LLPMr. Williams may be contacted at
williamsj@whiteandwilliams.com
Empowering Success: The Advantages of Female Attorneys in Construction Defect Law
December 11, 2023 —
Alexa Stephenson, Hoosai Kabiri & Ivette Kincaid - Kahana FeldPer the most recent U.S. Census records, women make up 50.4% of the U.S. population. It should come as no surprise then that women currently outnumber men in U.S. law schools. Nevertheless, as of 2022, only 38% of attorneys, 30% of federal judges, 22% of equity partners, and 12% of managing partners nationwide are comprised of women. While great strides have been made in the last century to increase gender equality in the legal field, there is undoubtedly still a long way to go.
Studies have shown that women in the workforce lead to a number of benefits not only to the business itself, but to a business’ employees and culture. In the realm of construction defect law in particular, the presence and contributions of female attorneys have become increasingly impactful and essential. As the legal landscape evolves, the benefits of having female attorneys practicing in this specialized field are becoming more evident, offering a range of advantages that contribute to a more diverse, comprehensive, and successful legal environment. These advantages include:
1. Diverse Perspectives: Female attorneys bring a unique perspective to the practice of construction defect law, enriching the field with their insights and experiences. Their diverse backgrounds and viewpoints can lead to innovative strategies and fresh approaches when tackling complex legal issues.
Reprinted courtesy of
Alexa Stephenson, Kahana Feld,
Hoosai Kabiri, Kahana Feld and
Ivette Kincaid, Kahana Feld
Ms. Stephenson may be contacted at astephenson@kahanafeld.com
Ms. Kabiri may be contacted at hkabiri@kahanafeld.com
Ms. Kincaid may be contacted at ikincaid@kahanafeld.com
Read the full story...Insurer Must Defend Additional Insured Though Its Insured is a Non-PartySE 2050 Is In Quixotic Pursuit of Eliminating Embodied Carbon in Building StructuresWSHB Ranks No.10 in Law360’s Best of Law Firms for WomenDefective Panels Threatening Profit at China Solar Farms: EnergyTexas Supreme Court: Breach of Contract Not Required to Prevail on Statutory Bad Faith ClaimNoncumulation Clause Limits Coverage to One OccurrenceExpired Contract Not Revived Due to Sovereign Immunity and the Ex Contractu ClauseNew York Labor Laws and Action Over ExclusionsBiden’s Solar Plans Run Into a Chinese WallFederal District Court Continues to Find Construction Defects do Not Arise From An Occurrence Quick Note: Can a Party Disclaim Liability in their Contract to Fraud?California Statutes Authorizing Public-Private Partnership ContractingLondon's Walkie Talkie Tower Voted Britain's Worst New BuildingInsurer's Appeal of Jury Verdict Rejected by Tenth CircuitBusiness Risk Exclusions (j) 5 and (j) 6 Found AmbiguousHolding the Bag for Pre-Tender Defense CostsClose Enough Only Counts in Horseshoes and Hand GrenadesInsured Versus Insured Clause Does Not Bar CoverageToolbox Talk Series Recap – Arbitration Motion PracticeSobering Facts for Construction Safety DayNewmeyer & Dillion Attorney Alan Packer Selected to the 2017 Northern California Super Lawyers ListS&P Near $1 Billion Mortgage Ratings Settlement With U.S.Action Needed: HB24-1230 Spells Trouble for Colorado Construction Industry and its InsurersConstruction Contract Basics: Attorney Fee ProvisionsThe NAR asks FAA to Amend their Drone Rules for Real Estate UseFEMA Offers to Review Hurricane Sandy ClaimsIn Colorado, Repair Vendors Can Bring First-Party Bad Faith Actions For Amounts Owed From an InsurerMissouri Construction Company Sues Carpenter Union for Threatening BehaviorIvanhoe Cambridge Plans Toronto Office Towers, TerminalCourt Affirms Duty to Defend Additional Insured ContractorEliminating Waste in Construction – An Interview with Turner BurtonUpdate Regarding New York City’s Climate Mobilization Act (CMA) and the Reduction of Carbon Emissions in New York CityDon’t Ignore the Dispute Resolution Provisions in Your Construction ContractGiant Floating Solar Flowers Offer Hope for Coal-Addicted KoreaThe Need for Situational Awareness in ConstructionRecommendations for Property Owners After A Hurricane: Submit a ClaimCourt’s Ruling on SB800 “Surprising to Some”One World Trade Center Due to Be America’s Tallest and World’s PriciestDid the Building Boom Lead to a Boom in Construction Defects?AFL-CIO Joins in $10 Billion Infrastructure PlanMontrose Language Interpreted: How Many Policies Are Implicated By A Construction Defect That Later Causes a Flood?Wells Fargo, JPMorgan Vexed by Low Demand for MortgagesComply with your Insurance Policy's Conditions Precedent (Post-Loss Obligations)SIGAR Report Finds +$15 Billion in “Waste, Fraud and Abuse” in AfghanistanNo Coverage for Faulty Workmanship Causing Property Damage to Insured's Product OnlyEnerpac Plays Critical Role in Industry-changing Discovery for Long Span Bridges at The University of Nebraska-LincolnAn Occurrence Under Builder’s Risk Insurance Policy Is Based on the Language in the PolicySpencer Mayer Receives Miami-Dade Bar Association's '40 Under 40' AwardOnce Again: Contract Terms MatterCrypto and NFTs Could Help People Become Real Estate Tycoonsprop="name">Your Construction Contract
Supreme Court of Kentucky Holds Plaintiff Can Recover for Stigma Damages in Addition to Repair Costs Resulting From Property DamageSaving Manhattan: Agencies, Consultants, Contractors Join Fight to Keep New York City Above WaterReplacement of Defective Gym Construction Exceeds Original CostInsurer Must Indemnify Additional Insured After SettlementConfidence Among U.S. Homebuilders Declines to Eight-Month LowNo Conflict in Successive Representation of a Closely-Held Company and Its Insiders Where Insiders Already Possess Company’s Confidential InformationJustice Didn’t Ensure Mortgage Fraud Was Priority, IG SaysMichigan Court of Appeals Remands Construction Defect CaseThe Enforceability of “Pay-If-Paid” Provisions Affirmed in New JerseyUsed French Fry Oil Fuels London Offices as Buildings Go GreenAustralians Back U.S. Renewables While Opportunities at Home EbbTo Sea or Not to Sea: Fifth Circuit Applies Maritime Law to Offshore Service Contract, Spares Indemnity Provision from Louisiana Oilfield Indemnity Act
