GRSM Team Obtains Defense Verdict for Homeowners’ Association in Orange County Superior Court
August 11, 2026 —
Gordon Rees Scully MansukhaniA Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani multi-state team, including Partners Christine Barker, Sean Ferron, and Keith Cramer, obtained a defense verdict on behalf of a homeowners’ association (HOA) in an Orange County Superior Court bench trial spanning two months.
The case began in 2022 when a homeowner sued after the Architectural Review Committee and HOA Board of Directors declined his teardown-and-rebuild plans due to view and aesthetic concerns. After a motion for summary judgment ruling in which the court found that the existing covenants, conditions, and restrictions (CC&Rs) did not protect views, the HOA held a special election to add explicit view protections to the CC&Rs. At the February 2025 trial call, the plaintiff sought leave to file a third amended complaint challenging the validity of that vote, drastically reframing the case from CC&R enforcement to one of election validity. A second plaintiff then filed a parallel action toward the end of the limitations period, and the two cases were consolidated.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Gordon Rees Scully Mansukhani
Conditional Payment Bond Consideration-Make Sure There Is Pay-If-Paid Provision
June 29, 2026 —
David Adelstein - Florida Construction Legal UpdatesIf a general contractor is going to have a conditional payment bond, it needs to ensure it subcontracts contain pay-if-paid or pay-when-paid provisions. This conditional payment language in subcontracts is the general contractor’s defense that it doesn’t have to pay a subcontractor UNTIL owner has paid the general contractor for the subcontractor’s work.
The general contractor (and the surety) can look at the conditional payment bond with the s. 713.245 legend stamped on its face designating the conditional nature of the bond, and assume the conditional structure is locked in against the bond: no payment from the owner, no obligation to the subcontractors under the bond. But what happens when the subcontracts contain no express conditional payment language despite having a valid conditional payment bond?
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
David Adelstein, Kirwin NorrisMr. Adelstein may be contacted at
dma@kirwinnorris.com
Beyond the Storm: How Non-Hurricane Catastrophes Expose Florida’s Construction Defect Blind Spot
August 11, 2026 —
Franchesco “Frank” Soto & Amanda L. Gonzalez - Ball JanikOn June 8, 2026, a magnitude 6.1 earthquake struck the Gulf near the coast of Cuba, the largest instrumentally recorded earthquake in the Gulf since seismic monitoring began in 1950. Buildings swayed, offices were evacuated, and many residents along the east coast of Florida, from Miami-Dade to Jacksonville, felt the ground shake. Although no tsunami followed and reported structural damage was limited, this event exposed a blind spot that Florida property owners, developers, and their counsel cannot afford to ignore: catastrophic stress on Florida buildings does not always come in the form of a named storm.
Florida property owners have grown accustomed to preparing for wind, storm surge, floods, and torrential rain. Far less attention is paid to earthquakes, sinkholes, tornadoes, hail, and non-tropical flooding, each of which can place unexpected stress on buildings not designed with those forces top of mind and can trigger deficiencies in buildings that were not otherwise known, expose design failures, and create an urgency for both insurance claims and subsequent litigation.
Non-Hurricane Triggers of Latent Defects
Seismic activity is the clearest example. Florida’s building code accounts for wind loads, not seismic forces, meaning even a moderate earthquake can reveal weaknesses in curtain wall systems, structural connections, or foundations that were already marginal. Sinkholes, driven by Florida’s karst limestone geology, remain a persistent threat, particularly in Central Florida, where subsurface voids can undermine foundations without warning. Non-tropical flooding, like the record rainfall that flooded South Florida in June 2024, can intrude through building envelopes and waterproofing systems that were never stress-tested for such volumes of water. Tornadoes and hail, while more localized, can cause roofing and envelope failures that mimic, mask, or trigger latent construction defects.
The Litigation and Coverage Disputes That Follow
When one of these events strikes a building already carrying undisclosed or unresolved construction defects, the resulting disputes become considerably more complex. Property owners and associations must move quickly to document existing conditions and distinguish damage caused by the event from pre-existing defective construction, the same causation issue that arises in the hurricane context under Chapter 558, but often without the benefit of established precedent or adjuster experience with these less common events.
Insurance coverage disputes frequently follow close behind. Carriers may dispute whether an earthquake, flood, or other peril is covered at all, particularly where policies contain earthquake or flood exclusions requiring separate endorsements, or anti-concurrent causation language that can bar coverage entirely when a covered peril combines with an uncovered one, such as pre-existing defective construction, to cause a loss. Sinkhole claims carry their own statutory framework under Florida law, requiring specific testing protocols and reporting before a claim is compensable. Developers and contractors, in turn, may find themselves defending Chapter 558 claims while simultaneously litigating with their own carriers over defense and indemnity obligations.
Practical Risk Mitigation Strategies
Property owners, associations, and developers can take several concrete steps to reduce their exposure. First, maintain thorough documentation, including engineering reports, maintenance logs, and photographs, well before any event occurs. This documentation is often the deciding factor in causation disputes. Second, engage structural engineers and consultants immediately following any seismic event, unusual flooding, or storm damage, regardless of whether a hurricane is involved. Prompt inspection preserves evidence and can help prevent inadvertent waiver of construction defect claims. Third, review insurance policies regularly with counsel or a broker to confirm earthquake, flood, and sinkhole coverage matches the property’s actual risk profile, rather than assuming a standard property policy responds to every peril. Fourth, avoid rushing to remediate before conditions are documented and/or before consulting counsel. Well-intentioned repairs can inadvertently compromise evidence needed to prove a defect claim.
The June earthquake was a reminder that Florida’s catastrophic risk profile extends beyond hurricane season. Property owners, associations, and developers who build readiness plans around all forms of catastrophic stress, not just named storms, will be far better positioned when the next unexpected event occurs.
Franchesco “Frank” Soto is a partner in
Ball Janik’s Construction Defect Practice Group in Miami. He may be reached at fsoto@balljanik.com.
Amanda L. Gonzalez is a litigation attorney in
Ball Janik’s Construction Defect Practice Group in Miami. She may be reached at agonzalez@balljanik.com.
Travelers Injury Impact Report Highlights Longer Recovery Times Amid Declining Injury Rates
May 05, 2026 —
The Travelers Companies, Inc.HARTFORD, Conn.--(BUSINESS WIRE)--The Travelers Companies, Inc. (NYSE: TRV) today released its 2026 Injury Impact Report, an analysis of more than 1.2 million workers compensation claims received by the company from 2021 through 2025. The report finds that even as workplace injury rates decline, the injuries that do occur are growing more complex and taking longer to heal – a trend driven by an aging workforce and the disproportionate vulnerability of first-year employees.
“The decrease in workplace injuries is a positive story, yet injured workers are still missing an average of 80 workdays,” said Claude Howard, Vice President of Workers Compensation Claim at Travelers. “This report is a reminder that progress doesn’t mean the risk environment requires any less attention, and an employer’s commitment to safety must keep pace with an ever-evolving workforce and injury landscape.”
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
The Travelers Companies, Inc.
Agent Not Liable for Loss Given Insured’s Vague Instructions for Coverage
April 08, 2026 —
Tred R. Eyerly - Insurance Law HawaiiThe Illinois Appellate Court affirmed the district court’s grant of summary judgment to the insured’s agent because there was no breach of duty. Jon Van Order v. Hauk, et al., 2025 Ill. App. Unpub. LEXIS 2378 (Ill. Ct. App. Dec. 23, 2025).
The insured began renovating a vacant home in October 2018. He met with agent Joseph Hauk and explained the property was vacant and would be going through renovations for the next several months. Hauk then procured a policy through Shelter Insurance Company insuring the vacant property against several specified perils. The policy provided coverage for water damage if “[t]he exterior of the building sustained a covered loss” and “that loss created an opening through which the water entered.” Damage caused by escaping water from within a plumbing system was excluded if: (1) the damage was caused by a “continuous or repeated leakage over a period of fourteen days or more” or (2) the insured premises had been vacant for 30 consecutive days immediately preceding the loss.
Read the full story...Reprinted courtesy of
Tred R. Eyerly, Damon Key Leong Kupchak HastertMr. Eyerly may be contacted at
te@hawaiilawyer.com
Arbitration in Construction Disputes: Process and Best Practices
July 27, 2026 —
Construction ExecutiveArbitration in construction disputes is a private process where owners, contractors, subcontractors, designers or suppliers present claims to one or more neutral arbitrators instead of taking the dispute through court. The arbitrator reviews evidence, hears testimony and issues a decision that is usually binding.
Construction arbitration is common because project disputes are technical, document-heavy and time-sensitive. Claims may involve schedule delays, disputed change orders, defective work, differing site conditions, payment, termination, indemnity, surety issues or professional liability.
Arbitration can be faster and more specialized than litigation, but speed is not guaranteed. Poor contract language, broad discovery, weak records and unclear damages can make arbitration expensive.
Reprinted courtesy of
Construction Executive, a publication of Associated Builders and Contractors. All rights reserved.
Read the full story...
Four Families Now Live in the Season Six Rock the Block Homes in Grantsville, Utah
April 20,
Congratulations to BWB&O for Ranking in The U.S. News – Best Lawyers ® as “Best Law Firms”!Arizona Rooftop Safety: Is it Adequate or Substandard?Builders Risk/Construction All Risks and Delay in Start-Up Coverage for Large Energy Projects: Protecting Revenue Before Operations BeginBHA Expands Construction Experts GroupQuick Note: October 1, 2023 Changes to Florida’s Construction StatutesType I Differing Site Conditions Claim is Not Easy to ProveTarriffs, a Pandemic and War: Construction Contracts Must Withstand the UnforeseeableOSHA ETS Heads to Sixth CircuitCalifornia MCLE Seminar at BHA Sacramento July 11th First Circuit Limits Insurers’ Right to Recoup Defense Costs or Settlement PaymentsConstructing a New American DreamCourt of Appeal: Privette Doctrine Does Not Apply to Landlord-Tenant RelationshipsFactual Issues Prevent Summary Judgment Determination on Coverage for Additional InsuredDiffering Site Conditions: What to Expect from the Court When You Encounter the UnexpectedYou’re Only as Good as Those with Whom You ContractTriable Issue of Fact Exists as to Insurer’s Obligation to Provide Coverage Under Occurrence PolicyLate Notice Bars Insured’s Claim for Water Leak DamageCalifornia Supreme Court Declines Request to Expand Exceptions to Privette Doctrine for Known HazardsConstruction Defects not Creating Problems for Bay BridgeAgency Principles Matter (Including When It Comes to Arbitration Provisions)XL Group Pairs with America Contractor’s Insurance Group to Improve Quality of ConstructionApplication of Set-Off When a Defendant Settles in Multiparty Construction DisputeThe Coronavirus, Zoom Meetings and Now a CCPA Class ActionFocusing on Design Elements of the 2014 World Cup StadiumsA Contract Is a Contract: Releases and Change Orders / Bilateral Modifications Are Construed as ContractsCourt of Appeal Puts the “Equity” in Equitable SubrogationSouth Carolina Legislature Redefining Occurrences to Include Construction Defects in CGL PoliciesThe Ups and Downs of Elevator Maintenance Contractor's Policy LimitsLet the 90-Day Countdown BeginArchitect, Engineer, and Design Professional Liens in California: A Different Animal than the Mechanics’ LienHarmon Hotel Construction Defect UpdateJust When You Thought General Contractors Were Necessary Parties. . .Insurers' Motion to Void Coverage for Failure to Attend EUO DeniedTenn. Court of Appeals Finally Clarifies Contractor Licensing Laws, Holding An “Underlicensed” Contractor Is Violation of Tennessee’s Consumer Protection ActEnergy Company Covered for Business Interruption Losses Caused by Fire and Resulting in Town-Ordered ShutdownNew Jersey Law regarding Prior Expert’s TestimonyWork without Permits may lead to Problems LaterInsurer Must Defend Construction Defect ClaimsEndorsement Excludes Replacement of Undamaged Property with Matching MaterialsDesign Immunity Does Not Shield Public Entity From Claim That it Failed to Warn of a Dangerous Condition Former Owner Not Liable for Defects Discovered After SaleHow Many Bridges Does the Chesapeake Bay Need?Ready, Fire, Aim: The Importance of Targeting Your Delay NoticesAn Oregon School District Files Suit Against Robinson Construction Co.Texas House Passes Medical Damages Reform: What It Means for Insurance Defense AttorneysJust Because You Can, Doesn’t Mean You Should. The “Retained Control” Exception to the Privette DoctrineNine ACS Lawyers Recognized by Best Lawyers®Insurer's Bad Faith is Actionable Tort for Purposes of Choice of Law AnalysisBuilders Beware: A New Class Of Defendants In Asbestos LawsuitsMassachusetts Appellate Court Confirms Construction Defects are Not Covered Under Commercial General Liability PoliciesFla. Researchers Probe 'Mother of All Sinkholes'Eighth Circuit Remands to Determine Applicability of Collapse ExclusionIn South Carolina, Insurer's Denial of Liability Does Not Waive Attorney-Client Privilege for Bad Faith ClaimNew York Developer gets Reprieve in Leasehold BattleVoluntary Dismissal of an Indemnity Claim Does Not Make the Subcontractor a “Prevailing Party,” Washington Court of Appeals HoldsMeet Orange County Bar Associations 2024 LeadersWork without Permits may lead to Problems LaterMaui Wildfire Cleanup Advances to Debris Removal PhaseNew York Nonprofit Starts Anti-Scaffold Law Video SeriesQuick Note: Aim to Avoid a Stay to your Miller Act Payment Bond ClaimFifth Circuit Rules that Settlements in Underlying Action Constitute "Other Insurance"Like Water For Chocolate: Insurer Prevails Over Chocolatier In Hurricane Sandy ClaimBright-Line Changes: Prompt Payment Act TrendsLas Vegas Harmon Hotel to be Demolished without OpeningFlorida Court Gives Parties Assigned a Subrogation Claim a Math LessonToolbox Talk Series: Direct Versus Consequential Damages--Is There a Clear Demarcation?Home Prices Up, Inventory DownThe Construction Defect Litigation Podcast: Navigating Multi-Party Construction Defect LitigationAt Lake Powell, Engineering Is Outpacing Colorado River PolicyThe Power of Team Bonding: Transforming Workplaces for the BetterColorado’s Workers’ Compensation Act and the Construction IndustrySan Francisco Bucks U.S. Trend With Homeownership GainsSickened Employees at Kimley-Horn Lead to Multi-million-dollar Rent DisputeGeneral Contractor’s Excess Insurer Denied Equitable Contribution From Subcontractor’s Excess InsurerIs It Time to Digitize Safety?Homeowners Sue Over Sinkholes, Use Cash for Other ThingsMechanic’s Liens and Contracts: A RoundupQuick Note: Independent Third-Party Spoliation Of Evidence ClaimGSA Releases Updated Standards to Accelerate Federal Buildings Toward Zero EmissionsMotion for Summary Judgment Gets Pooped UponEfficient Proximate Cause Applies to Policy's Collapse ProvisionsWest Coast Casualty Construction Defect Seminar Announced for 2014Ninth Circuit Clears the Way for Review of Oregon District Court’s Rulings in Controversial Climate Change CaseCalifornia Precludes Surety from Asserting Pay-When-Paid Provision as Defense to Payment Bond ClaimFranchisors Should Consider Signing a Conditional Lease Assignment Rather Than a Franchisee’s LeaseConstruction Litigation Roundup: “Too Soon?”Additional Insured Secures Defense Under Subcontractor's Policy
